Comparison of the results of two methods of modeling the response surface and artificial neural network with experimental results of effective parameters in cobalt electrowinning

Document Type : Research Article


Nuclear Fuel Cycle Research School, Nuclear Science and Technology Research Institute, Tehran, IRAN


In this study, the electrowinning process was investigated in the production of metal cobalt from a low chloride solution concentration by both response surface methodology and artificial neural network. Initially, the solvent extraction process from two different feeds was performed to recover cobalt ions by dithiophosphinic acid to the organic phase and transferring it to the aqueous phase with HCl solution (1 M). Then, the metal production process was performed using the electrowinning method and examining the effective parameters such as time, pH of solution, ion concentration and current ampere. The optimization conditions for pH of aqueous solution, time, cobalt ion concentration, and ampere were obtained equal to 4, 40, 0.008 mol/L, 1 A, respectively. The results showed that the temperature of 15 ◦ C was more favorable for the process. Increasing the current ampere, time, and concentration of ions in the solution helps to increase the current efficiency. The acidity values ​​in the aqueous phase are essential for the electrowinning process and depend on the system’s conditions. The XRF and EDX analysis results showed that in optimum conditions, metal cobalt with purity above 99.8% was accumulated on the cathode surface. The modeling results of two methods showed that the artificial neural network is in better agreement with the experimental results than the response surface methodology.


Main Subjects

[1] Crundwell, F.K., M. S. Moats, M.S., Ramachandram, V., Robinson, T.G., Davenport, W.G., "Extractive Metallurgy of Nickel, Cobalt and Platinium Group", Elsevier, UK (2011).
[2] Watt, S., "The elements Cobalt", Marshall Cavendish Benchmark, New York (2007).
[3] Johanson, P., "Understanding the Elements of the Periodic Table Cobalt", RSC Advances, New York (2008).
[4] Crundwell, F., Moats, M., Ramachandran, V., Robinson, T., Davenport, W.G., "Cobalt – Occurrence, Production, Use and Price," in Extractive Metallurgy of Nickel, Cobalt and Platinum Group Metals., Elsevier, New York (2011).
[5] Moats, M.S., Davenport, W.G., Nickel and Cobalt Production, in "Treatise on Process Metallurgy", Elsevier, New York (2014).
[6] Swain, B., Cho, S.S., Lee, G.H., Lee, C.G., Uhm, S. Extraction/Separation of Cobalt by Solvent Extraction: A Review, Applied Chemical  Engineering, 26: 631-639 (2015).
[7] Huang, Y., Zhang, Z., Cao, Y., Han, G., Peng, W., Zhu, X., Overview of Cobalt Resources and Comprehensive Analysis of Cobalt Recoveryfrom Zinc Plant Purification Residue- A Review, Hydrometallurgy, 193:105327 (2020).
[8] Naboychenko, S.S. Murashova, I.B., Neikov, O.D., Production of Cobalt and Cobalt-Alloy Powders, in "Handbook of non-ferrous metal powders", Elsevier, New York (2009).
[9] Cheng, C.Y., Barnard, K.R., Zhang, W., Robinson, D.J., Synergistic Solvent Extraction of Nickel and Cobalt: A Review of Recent Developments," Solvent Extraction Ion Exchange, 29:719-754 (2011).
[10] Sole, K.C., Parker, J., Cole, P.M., Mooiman, M.B., "Flowsheet Options for Cobalt Recovery in African Copper–cobalt Hydrometallurgy Circuits," Mineral Processing and Extractive Metallurgy Review, 40: 194-206 (2019).
[11] Darvishi, D., Haghshenas, D.F., Alamdarib, E.K., Sadrnezhaad, S.K., Halali, M., Synergistic Effect of Cyanex 272 and Cyanex 302 on Separation of Cobalt and Nickel by D2EHPA, Hydrometallurgy, 77: 227-238 (2005).
[13] Huang, J.H., Kargl-Simard, C., Alfantazi, A.M., Electrowinning of Cobalt from a Sulphate-Chloride Solution," Canadian Metallurgical Quarterly, 43: 163-172 (2004).
[14] Prandhan, N., Singh, P., Tripathy, B.C., Das, S.C., Electrowinning of Cobalt from Acidic Sulphate Solutions-Effect of Chloride Ion, Minerals Engineering, 14: 115-183 (2001).
[15] Akre, T.,"Electrowinning of Cobalt from Chloride Solutions: Anodic Deposition of Cobalt Oxide on DSA®," PhD, Norwegian University of Science and Technology, (2008).
[16] Das, S.C., Subbaiah T., Electrowinning of Cobalt, I. Winnig from Pure Sulphate Bath, Hydrometallurgy, 12:317-333 (1984).
[17] Sharma, I.G., Alex, P., Bidaye, A.C., Suri, A.K., Electrowinning of Cobalt from Sulphate Solutions, Hydrometallurgy, 80: 132-138 (2005).
[18] Song, Q., Zhao, Y., Wang, C., Xie, H., Yin, H., Ning, Z., Bubble-Assisted Densification of Cobalt Deposit During Electrowinning in CoCl2 Solution, Hydrometallurgy, 189: 10511 (2019).
[19] Kongstein, O.E., Haarberg, G.M., Thonstad, J. Current Efficiency and Kinetics of Cobalt Electrodeposition in Acid Chloride Solutions. Part 1: The Influence of Current Density, pH and Temperature, Journal of Applied Electrochemistry, 37: 669-674 (2007).
[21] Lu, J., Dreisinger, D., Glück, T., Cobalt Electrowinning – A Systematic Investigation for High Quality Electrolytic Cobalt Production, Hydrometallurgy, 178: 19-29 (2018).
[22] Elsherief, A.E., Effects of Cobalt, Temperature  and Certain Impurities Upon Cobalt Electrowinning from Sulfate Solutions, Journal of Applied Electrochemistry, 33: 43-49 (2003).
[23] Tripathy, B.C., Singh, P., Muir, D. M., Effect of Manganese(II) and Boric Acid on the Electrowinning of Cobalt from Acidic Sulfate Solutions, Metallurgical and Materials Transactions B, 32:395-399, (2001).
[24] Bertuol, D.A., Amado, F.D.R., Veit, H., Ferreira, J.Z., Bernardes, A.M., Recovery of Nickel and Cobalt from Spent NiMH Batteries by Electrowinning, Chemical Engineering and Technology, 35: 2084-2092 (2012).
[25] Lin, H.K., Wu, X.J., Rao, P.D., The Electrowinning of Copper from a Cupric Chloride Solution, JOM, 43: 60-65 (1991).
[26] ج. مفیدی، الکتروشیمی صنعتی، دانشگاه تهران، 1388.
[27] Hafeez, A., Taqvi, S.A.A., Fazal, T., Javed, F., Khan, Z., Amjad, U.S., Optimization on Cleaner Intensification of Ozone Production Using Artificial Neural Network and Response Surface Methodology: Parametric and Comparative Study, Journal of Cleaner Production, 252: 119833 (2020).
[30] Dantas, T.N.C., Cabral, T.J.O., Neto, A.A.D., Moura, M.C., Enrichmnent of Patchoulol Extracted from Patchouli (Pogostemon Cablin) Oil by Molecular Distillation Using Response Surface and Artificial Neural Network Models,Journal of Industrial and Engineering Chemistry, 81:219-227 (2020).
[31] Li, L., Zhai, Y., Jin, Y., J. Wang, Wang, H., Ma, M., Stability, Thermal Performance and Artificial Neural Network Modeling of Viscosity and Thermal Conductivity of Al2O3-Ethylene Glycol Nanofluids, Powder Technology, 363: 360-368 (2020).
[32] Marczenko, Z., Balcerzak, M., "Separation, Preconcentration and Spectrophotometry in Inorganic Analysis", Elsevier, New York (2000).
[33] Jeffrey, M.I., Choo, W.L., Breuer, P.L. The Effect of Additives and Impurities on the Cobalt Electrowinning Process, Mineral Engineering, 13:1231-1241 (2000).
[34] Mishra, K.G., Singh, P., Muir, D.M. Electrowinning of Cobalt from Sulphate Solutions Contaminated with Organic Impurities, Hydrometallurgy, 65:97-102 (2002).
[35] Huang, J.H., Kargl-Simard, C., Alfantazi, A.M. Electrowinning of Cobalt from a Sulfate-Chloride Solution," Canadian Metallurgical Quarterly, 43:163-172 (2004).
[36] DAS, T.S.S.C, Electrowinning of Cobalt from a Sulphate Bath Containing H3BO3 and NaF, Journal of Applied Electrochemistry, 17: 675-683 (1987).
[37] Kongstein, O.E., Haarberg, G.M., Thonstad, J., Anodic Deposition of Cobalt Oxide during Electrowinning of Cobalt in a Chloride Electrolyte, Journal of The Electrochemical Society, 158: D77 (2011).